When two wrongs DO make a right

marilynfl

Moderator
Last night I did EXACTLY what I told my caramel candy class NOT TO DO: I multi-tasked making a batch of caramel candy stovetop while baking a batch of caramel popcorn with nuts.

So first off, curse that class for asking about caramel corn. I've reached seven decades blissfully hating caramel corn, mainly because my only experience with that sticky grain was a box of Cracker Jacks. Please note, Cracker Jacks is the perfect gift for a multi-child family: each kid got their own box with its own prize. No sharing, no arguing...so here's me, tearing open the box, grabbing the prize, eating the nuts and throwing everything else away. Six decades later, I still blissfully hated caramel corn, but after researching it for the class, I felt I had to try and make it.

And curses, it turns out that I DO like caramel corn. What I don't like is Cracker Jack caramel corn because...wait for it...Cracker Jack uses DARK Karo and molasses, neither of which I like. When those are eliminated, what must remain is...damn it, very tasty caramel.

So last night I was on my THIRD batch of caramel corn with nuts (guess what the neighbors are getting?) when I decided to also make my caramel candy. Somewhere in between baking the caramelized popcorn, my caramel candy temperature went to 252 degrees...which at my altitude means not chewy, but hard, suck-it caramel. Caramelization process is a science...and I blew it. That was Screw Up #1. Meanwhile, since my mind was on the caramel candy, I finally noticed the nuts were still sitting on the counter--and not with the caramel corn baking so >> Screw Up #2.

Then how did I make lemonade out of these two lemons? Well, I added ~1/2 C of heavy cream to a pot, and chiseled the hard candy into pieces. Then I melted it into a sauce, took 1 cup of the thick sauce, added a bit more butter and 1/2 tsp baking soda and when it foamed, poured it over the peanuts and cinnamon cashews. Baked at 225 degrees for an hour, stirring every twenty minutes. When they cooled off, I tasted it to see whether the entire batch would go in the garbage.

Holy moly...it tastes wonderful! I think it's because while the popcorn just has melted brown sugar and not caramelized sugar with heavy cream, there is none of that gritty sugary mouth-feel. It’s just sublime.

Thankfully, I'll NEVER be able to duplicate it again.

IMG_4517.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Last night I did EXACTLY what I told my caramel candy class NOT TO DO: I multi-tasked making a batch of caramel candy stovetop while baking a batch of caramel popcorn with nuts.

So first off, curse that class for asking about caramel corn. I've reached seven decades blissfully hating caramel corn, mainly because my only experience with that sticky grain was a box of Cracker Jacks. Please note, Cracker Jacks is the perfect gift for a multi-child family: each kid got their own box with its own prize. No sharing, no arguing...so here's me, tearing open the box, grabbing the prize, eating the nuts and throwing everything else away. Six decades later, I still blissfully hated caramel corn, but after researching it for the class, I felt I had to try and make it.

And curses, it turns out that I DO like caramel corn. What I don't like is Cracker Jack caramel corn because...wait for it...Cracker Jack uses DARK Karo and molasses, neither of which I like. When those are eliminated, what must remain is...damn it, very tasty caramel.

So last night I was on my THIRD batch of caramel corn with nuts (guess what the neighbors are getting?) when I decided to also make my caramel candy. Somewhere in between baking the caramelized popcorn, my caramel candy temperature went to 252 degrees...which at my altitude means not chewy, but hard, suck-it caramel. Caramelization process is a science...and I blew it. That was Screw Up #1. Meanwhile, since my mind was on the caramel candy, I finally noticed the nuts were still sitting on the counter--and not with the caramel corn baking so >> Screw Up #2.

Then how did I make lemonade out of these two lemons? Well, I added ~1/2 C of heavy cream to a pot, and chiseled the hard candy into pieces. Then I melted it into a sauce, took 1 cup of the thick sauce, added a bit more butter and 1/2 tsp baking soda and when it foamed, poured it over the peanuts and cinnamon cashews. Baked at 225 degrees for an hour, stirring every twenty minutes. When they cooled off, I tasted it to see whether the entire batch would go in the garbage.

Holy moly...it tastes wonderful! I think it's because while the popcorn just has melted brown sugar and not caramelized sugar with heavy cream, there is none of that gritty sugary mouth-feel, it's just sublime.

Thankfully, I'll NEVER be able to duplicate it again.

View attachment 3012
Much better than my fudge disaster that did go in the trash, twice. Since the new to me goodwill candy thermometer turned out to be highly inaccurate, I had to chisel my hard crack stage fudge out of my ka, the first batch I did try to reheat with water magic, but failed (but not gritty!)
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5225.jpeg
    IMG_5225.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 0
Maria, did the chocolate seize up? Because you can still save that chocolate for another use…you just can't temper it. Try heating some heavy cream and maybe you can end up with a creamy ganache.
 
Last night I did EXACTLY what I told my caramel candy class NOT TO DO: I multi-tasked making a batch of caramel candy stovetop while baking a batch of caramel popcorn with nuts.

So first off, curse that class for asking about caramel corn. I've reached seven decades blissfully hating caramel corn, mainly because my only experience with that sticky grain was a box of Cracker Jacks. Please note, Cracker Jacks is the perfect gift for a multi-child family: each kid got their own box with its own prize. No sharing, no arguing...so here's me, tearing open the box, grabbing the prize, eating the nuts and throwing everything else away. Six decades later, I still blissfully hated caramel corn, but after researching it for the class, I felt I had to try and make it.

And curses, it turns out that I DO like caramel corn. What I don't like is Cracker Jack caramel corn because...wait for it...Cracker Jack uses DARK Karo and molasses, neither of which I like. When those are eliminated, what must remain is...damn it, very tasty caramel.

So last night I was on my THIRD batch of caramel corn with nuts (guess what the neighbors are getting?) when I decided to also make my caramel candy. Somewhere in between baking the caramelized popcorn, my caramel candy temperature went to 252 degrees...which at my altitude means not chewy, but hard, suck-it caramel. Caramelization process is a science...and I blew it. That was Screw Up #1. Meanwhile, since my mind was on the caramel candy, I finally noticed the nuts were still sitting on the counter--and not with the caramel corn baking so >> Screw Up #2.

Then how did I make lemonade out of these two lemons? Well, I added ~1/2 C of heavy cream to a pot, and chiseled the hard candy into pieces. Then I melted it into a sauce, took 1 cup of the thick sauce, added a bit more butter and 1/2 tsp baking soda and when it foamed, poured it over the peanuts and cinnamon cashews. Baked at 225 degrees for an hour, stirring every twenty minutes. When they cooled off, I tasted it to see whether the entire batch would go in the garbage.

Holy moly...it tastes wonderful! I think it's because while the popcorn just has melted brown sugar and not caramelized sugar with heavy cream, there is none of that gritty sugary mouth-feel. It’s just sublime.

Thankfully, I'll NEVER be able to duplicate it again.

View attachment 3020
You're halfway to Tijuana Trash--try it! Was a big hit on Sunday. I subbed corn chips (2 snack bags of dipsy doodles about to expire-the "trash" part LOL :) for the Chex cereal and threw in some broken pretzels.
 
Maria, did the chocolate seize up? Because you can still save that chocolate for another use…you just can't temper it. Try heating some heavy cream and maybe you can end up with a creamy ganache.
I tried that and it was too far gone. It took hot water to just get it out of the pan. I couldn’t lift the tilt head because it was cemented in there. Hot water and an ice pick freed it.
 
Oh caramel may be the death of me. I lost my modified instructions from the Canadian Living Recipe for Millionaires Bar.

What I remembered was cooking it to 250F ended up with a caramel that was very hard - not at all enjoyable. I must have made at least 4 more batches before I settled on 241 or 242F that gave me my soft yet not too soft filling. But I didn't remember that when I attempted them two days ago and thought I would give 247F a try. Into the garbage they went after they cooled and they were worse than taffy.

Yesterday I got the temp right but when I went to make the chocolate topping (Using my chocolate ganache recipe - not following their instructions.) I must have gotten the cream too hot because my ganache was a chocolate mess - into the garbage that went. Thankfully my second attempt, the one where I actually paid attention to what I was doing, worked beautifully. And I had a perfect pan of these homemade "Twix" bars to give to a friend for her Christmas Eve party tonight (Her favorite bar cookie). When I make this I double all ingredients and make in a 9" x 13" pan.
 
Deb, what elevation are you at? My recipe is from Theo's Chocolates and theirs is only 725 feet. His recipe says to cook the caramel to 252. But i'm at 3,000 feet and that means I drop ONE degree for each 500 feet. So I cook mine to 247.

Usually.
 
Last edited:
I do admire your perserverance. I cannot find my candy thermometer (I am so bad at finding things) so have been using my meat probe for temps. I'm afraid it is just not quite accurate enough. So I made something like you did and had to recover it. Oh well, no one knew.
 
That shouldn’t need much adjustment. It sounds like your dessert just need it to be a soft set…that is around 243-244 for me. I can still cut it but the cubes are very very soft.

But once the temp gets over 238 it can change rapidly and if you aren’t moving the caramel around and have a very reliable thermometer, it can get away from you very quickly.
 
Back
Top