Coffee Cake throwdown-- Michael's or Cafe Beaujolais? :)

monj

Well-known member
Trying to figure out which one to make!

Both have such raves-- has anyone made both and determined a winner?

Make ahead?

Thinking about putting one on my Mother's Day brunch menu.

Thanks!

M

 
They're both supposed to be great, so this is a hard decision. I haven't made either one of them,

since I like fruit in my coffee cakes. Some of my favorites are: Tons of Blueberry Coffee Cake, Raspberry Cream Cheese Coffee Cake, Streusel Topped Triple Berry Coffee Cake, and Strawberry Coffee Cake.
Orange Marmalade Coffee Cake is good too, but a little too sweet for me.

 
I've made both....Cafe's more often simply because I had that recipe for years.

Michael's is very good...the crumb topping is layered through the cake, while the Cafe version is dropped on top. Both have a soft crumb that's perfect.

I do have to say that I reduce the sugar a bit in the Cafe version now and almost always sprinkle chocolate chips on the last 5 minutes so they melt slightly.

It seems to take longer to cook than it says, at least for me.

 
I do Cafe Beaujolais and sprinkle blueberries and then put on topping!(more)

Probably could do the same with other fruits!
This is my fave; esy and gets rave reviews and requests for the recipe.

 
Mo, I'd have to say a winning factor is serving it slightly warm. If I'm

bringing a 9x11" pan into work, I measure out all the ingredients the night before, even blending in the oil mix and separating it.

Next morning, I'm up at 5:00, mix the batter and pop it into the oven and 45 minutes later, wrap it in a heavy bath towel (top open). Then I have an hour drive into work.

Folks are eating it around 7:30 to 8:00 and it still has a residual warmness to it.

I enjoy it all day long, but that first warm bite is the best.

 
That sounds great--I'll bake it in time for guests to arrive. smileys/smile.gif How much sugar

do you reduce by? I'm always trying to find the magic ratio between the flour and how little sugar I can use without radically affecting the outcome.

 
I'm pretty much a coward. I only reduce the brown sugar by 1/4C.

When I ask folks at work if it's too sweet, they say no. Go figure.

I also re-read the recipe and noticed two things:

1. I never use the full amount of cinnamon...I don't add the extra dose in the topping.
2. In the notes, I say I don't cook it as long as it says. So now I'm confused because I thought I had to cook this one longer. Best check it carefully before removing.

PS: Your house is gonna smell so good!

 
Thanks! Now I'm torn between the CI recipe that just arrived today

in my inbox for the NY style coffee cake.
Doing a side by side recipe comparison.
Wonder if anyone has made this one.
Those crumbs look really good!

 
Back
Top