Does anyone have experience with skirt steaks. I have purchased two, very thick small steak

karennoca

Well-known member
I have read about marinating them but the one recipe I was interested in uses lime juice. The author said it could be marinated overnight. However, I have found that marinades with lime actually tend to cook the meat partially if you marinate too long and they turn out terrible. They also say to cut the steak into three to four sections prior to marinating then cooking the slices. I want to marinate the entire chunk, grill, and then cut. Is it a tender piece of meat?

I have done flat iron steaks, and just about every other cut, but this one. They seem very popular right now at our local meat cutting shop.

 
Skirt steak is fajitas and it is tough. Thats why it is usually cut thin and then

sliced in thin strips across the grain to eat. Think long "stringy" muscles like brisket.


From Culinary Arts:
Skirt steak is one of the most flavorful cuts of beef, and even though it's one of the tougher cuts, with a lot of connective tissue, it's still a great steak for grilling.

Skirt steak actually comes from either of two separate muscles inside the chest and abdominal cavity, below the ribs, in the section known as the beef plate primal cut.

The two muscles are the diaphragm muscle, or outside skirt, and the transversus abdominis muscle, or inside skirt.

Outside Skirt Vs. Inside Skirt

Outside skirt is attached to the chest wall, running diagonally from the 6th to the 12th rib. It's covered with a thick membrane which is the diaphragm itself (the steak is the muscle that moves the diaphragm).

Outside skirt is plainly visible on the beef carcass as a long, diagonal flap attached to the chest wall, It's called "outside" because it is affixed to the outside of the body wall.


Inside skirt is situated below and a little bit further back from the outside skirt. But unlike the outside skirt, inside skirt is located within the body wall itself, which is why it's called "inside."

The inside skirt muscle lies flat across the lower part of the the ribs and extending even beyond the ribs, into the beef flank primal cut, which is part of the hindquarter of the animal.

As a result, a wide flap of meat at the rear of the transversus abdominis muscle is usually excluded, and ends up part of the flank instead.

Incidentally (and I wasn't going to mention this, but then realized that I should): skirt steak is NOT flank steak. For some reason the two are referred to interchangeably sometimes, but they are not the same.

Skirt Steak: Long, Flat Muscles, Thick Grain

Inside and outside skirt are pretty similar: both are long, flat muscles with very thick grain that runs across the length of the muscle.

Outside skirt is a bit thicker than inside skirt, and more uniform in shape. Inside skirt is thinner, with a slightly more irregular shape (see the photo above).

But they're both long, flat and narrow pieces of meat, about 20 to 24 inches long, and maybe three to four inches across once they've been trimmed.

A whole inside skirt might weigh two pounds, and maybe a bit less for an outside skirt. But inside skirt will shrink a bit more when you cook it as the muscle fibers tighten up.

Because of its thickness and regular shape, outside skirt is what restaurants and other foodservice operations prefer to use for making fajitas and other grilled skirt steak dishes.

And because there are only two skirt steaks per side of beef, one inside and one outside, pretty much every outside skirt from every side of beef ends up in a commercial kitchen of some kind.

So when you see skirt steak at the butcher shop, it'll almost always be inside skirt.

Outside skirt is encased in a membrane which needs to be removed before preparing it. If the meat has been dry-aged, that membrane will be like paper, and will peel off pretty easily.

With wet-aged meat, the membrane will be wet, and it's a little bit trickier to peel it off without tearing the meat. As I said, you're most likely to find inside skirt, but a good butcher will have peeled and trimmed it in any case.

Both outside and inside skirt have a good amount of fat within and between the muscle strands, which helps keep it moist when grilling it. The grain on inside skirt is a little bit wider, so it might have slightly more fat.

In either case, most of the surface fat (as opposed to the intramuscular fat I mentioned above) is going to be removed by the butcher.

Preparing Skirt Steak

A lot of skirt steak recipes call for marinating the meat before grilling it, and because of its looser structure, skirt steak will absorb the flavors of the marinade quite well. But there's no need to marinate it for more than 30 minutes or so, as marinating does not tenderize meat.

Skirt steak is tough, however, so the best way to cook it is very quickly over the hottest grill you can get. As a matter of fact, some people will even skip the grill altogether and cook it directly on the coals.

This actually works quite well, because you do not want to overcook skirt steak. Cooking it directly on the coals gets the surface of the meat nice and brown very quickly, without cooking the inside of the meat for too long.

You can do this in a cast-iron skillet too, or under the broiler, or anything else you can get extremely hot. Just remember, very hot and very fast. Under no circumstances should skirt steak be cooked past medium rare. It'll be way too tough.

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, skirt steak absolutely must be sliced thinly against the grain. Because it's so long, your best bet is to cut it into shorter sections first and then slice those sections across the grain.

If you're making fajitas, however (and skirt steak is amazing for fajitas), or any other stir-fry dish, you should slice it up first (against the grain!) and then marinate and cook it.

http://culinaryarts.about.com/od/beefporkothermeats/fl/What-is-Skirt-Steak.htm

 
Good information Melissa. I LOVE skirt steak; I don't marinate, usually because of time, but

slice in really small slices and serve over a platter of a fun salad. I drizzle the vinaigrette over the dish. YUM! So refreshing!

 
We also love skirt steak, either as fajitas or as a little "steak" on its own. Very flavorful

but as said, not tender unless cut against the grain.
As for the lime juice, I think this is truer for poultry and for sure, seafood, as to the "cooking". BUT I was really glad to see this statement in the explanatory post because so many think ordinary "marinades" tenderize meat. They do if they contain papain and such, but it is really for flavorizing.
" But there's no need to marinate it for more than 30 minutes or so, as marinating does not tenderize meat."

 
I have always heard from the meat cutters in my husbands family that vinegar tenderizes meats

and that is why our famous family flank steak contains a touch of vinegar, along with sherry wine, soy sauce, and garlic. I usually add a little apple cider vinegar to marinades for beef. So is this an old wives tale or is it correct?

 
Thanks Melissa, this is the best info on skirt I've seen. It explains why I can't find an outside

skirt. I've heard they're more tender, that's probably why they all end up in restaurants, etc.

 
Interesting that Shirley Corriher contradicts herself in the article Charley

mentioned and her book CookWise.

Marinated Grilled Skirt Steak

2 med shallots chopped
1 T dried thyme leaves
3 T packed dark brown sugar
1/4 cup soy sauce
2 T balsamic vinegar
3 T Worcestershire sauce

So, there you go, in her book she says vinegar tenderizes and in the FineCooking article she says it doesn't.

I whole-heartedly agree with her about pineapple and papaya...stay away! I tried doing ham and fresh pineapple kabobs. The ham turned out so mushy we couldn't eat them.

 
In her book, I guess she says this tenderizes?

CI has a pretty extensive list
https://www.cooksillustrated.com/how_tos/5562-marinating-myths

I know I was a "believer" for most of my currently long life!! LOL BUT I did find out about papain a long time ago and got rid of that!!
There was also a time in my earlier lifetime when really tender meat wasn't a "norm". My mother beat the heck out of round steak to make country fried, etc.

 
Back
Top