Got this off of Gay's Cheese Media Site, Which Mac&Cheese recipe do you think (Thanks Gay)

kendall

Well-known member
by just looking at the recipe would be best?

Deb's Mac and Cheese, or Extra-Creamy Mac and Cheese from Gay's Cheese media site?

I have made Deb's many times, and I have ALWAYS had bad luck with trying to make Mac and Cheese with real cheese. If any of you knew Deb, she was a Paula Deen!!! I only met her once, and I loved her. I got to spend 2 days at a large Epi party with her, and I didn't get to know her enough, but Paula Deen could have taken smile and southern charm lessons from Deb.

I would like to try this other Mac and Cheese recipe, but I don't want to waste ingredients if it turns out bad.

By the way, I rarely use Velveeta, it's not real cheese imho, but it is great in Deb's recipe.

NUMBER 1: Extra-Creamy Mac and Cheese

http://www.saycheesemedia.com/recipe.php?id=42

Makes four main course or 8 side-dish servings

•6 tablespoons unsalted butter, divided use

•1 cup panko bread crumbs

•2 large eggs

•1 can (12 ounces) evaporated milk

•½ teaspoon each: dry mustard, hot red pepper sauce

•8 ounces sharp Cheddar cheese, grated

•4 ounces Monterey Jack cheese, grated

•8 ounces medium shell pasta

•Salt and pepper to taste

1.Melt 2 tablespoons butter in a medium skillet. Add panko crumbs and cook, stirring often, until they are crisp and golden. Remove from the pan and set aside.

2.In a mixing bowl, lightly whisk eggs. Add the evaporated milk (reserving several tablespoons), dry mustard, pepper sauce. Lightly toss together the two cheeses.

3.Cook pasta according to package; drain well and return to the pan. Add remaining 4 tablespoons butter and stir to melt. Stirring as you do so, add the milk mixture, off the heat, then add about 2/3 of the cheese. Place pan over low heat and cook gently until mixture is smooth and creamy, 3 to 4 minutes. Add salt and pepper to taste along with the remaining cheese. If mixture seems thick, add reserved evaporated milk as needed. Sprinkle each portion with some of the bread crumbs and serve at once.

NUMBER 2: Deb's Mac and Cheese

1/3 of a 2 lb. block of Velveeta cheese

1 tsp. salt

2 cups elbow macaroni

½ stick butter

1 egg

2 cups whole milk

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Slice cheese with a

cheese cutter and set aside.

Fill a large saucepan with water, add salt and bring to a boil. Add macaroni and return to a boil. Cook forapproximately 9 minutes until just tender, then turninto a colander.

While draining the macaroni, put butter in the

still-warm pot, and place the sliced cheese on. Place lid on pot while going on to the next step.

Beat the egg and mix it with the milk. Set aside.

Pour still-hot macaroni into pot with the cheese and

butter and stir until the cheese is melted. (Doesn't

have to be completely melted.) Add the egg and milk

mixture and stir. Add more milk and stir as needed to

just cover the macaroni.

Pour into a greased, two-quart casserole dish and bake

for 45 minutes or until slightly browned.

 
Have you tried Hoffman's super sharp cheddar? It is processed, therefore gives that smooth

texture but a bit more oomph to it than Velveeta, to my taste. I can't always find it, but it's really good in mac and cheese, cheese scalloped potatoes, grilled cheese sandwiches, etc.

My mom made great mac and cheese using Velveeta, she didn't use eggs but the method was similar to Debs. She just layered the cooked macaroni with lumps of butter and pieces of cheese, poured a milk/cream mixture over it and baked. It came out creamy and delicious.

 
I think the first recipe is the way to go (the other looks kinda bland) but I'd add 1/4 lb Velveeta>

for creaminess. I did a Mac & Cheese off over the weekend and used something similar to the 1st recipe but to my great surprise, it wasn't "cheesey" enough. I added some velveeta to the uncooked leftovers and (to quote Emeril, gulp) BAM!

I also used part panko, part fresh bread crumbs. I think the panko alone would be a little too hard. Good luck tho.

 
MMMM!!!! ROFL Steve, I never thought I'd hear you say use Velveeta, Kind of like Marc and Spam!

I thought it was a bit too much with the panko too. I met Deb at Manz's party, and I can tell you that Deb's mac and cheese is serious southern comfort food. I bought a bunch of hatch green chiles at Manz's and added them and some ham to Deb's recipe, OH! BUT THERE IS HEAVEN ON EARTH.

But I do want to try some real mac and cheese. The Hoffman's cheese sounds awesome! I will look for a source.

 
Back
Top