Help! I'm making these cookies and they seem to be missing something...Can ya'll take a look

traca

Well-known member
at this recipe and tell me...does it need an egg? (No one in the comments actually discuss the finished product.)

The batter seemed really dry, so I did opt to add an egg but now I'm wondering if I messed them up.

I'm bringing the dough to a cookie bake off later today and was hoping to bring something delicious...but now I'm concerned.

Any ideas?

Here's the recipe:

Chocolate dipped pistachio and cardamom cookies

Makes 30 of each flavour (60 total)

1/2 cup softened butter

1 cup packed golden sugar

2 tablespoons cream

1 tablespoon vanilla

1 teaspoon baking soda

1 + 3/4 cup flour

1 teaspoon cardamom

1/3 + 1/4 cup finely chopped pistachios

1/3 + 1/4 cup finely chopped candied ginger

3 squares semisweet baking chocolate

1/2 tablespoon vegetable shortening

Preheat oven to 375F

Cream butter and sugar in the bowl of your upright mixer. Add milk, vanilla, baking soda and beat to combine. Add in flour and third at a time, scraping down the sides of the mixing bowl a few times during the process as needed. Turn off machine, remove dough and separate into two halve. Put one half back into he mixer and add in the cardamom and pistachio. Mix thoroughly. Remove the pistachio dough and pop the second half of the basic dough into the mixer. Add in chopped ginger and mix to combine thoroughly.

Roll out each dough onto waxed paper, using a little flour to stop it from sticking to the rolling pin if necessary. Roll each ball out in roughly a rectangle shape until it is no more than 2 millimetres thick. Using a standard plastic ruler or a piece of cardboard cut into a strip 4 cm by 25 cm use a sharp knife to carefully cut the dough into little 4 cm by 4 cm squares using the ruler or cardboard strip as a guide.

Use the flat of a sharp and wide knife to pick up each cookie square and transfer to a cookie sheet. Bake for 6 minutes. Remove the pans from the oven and allow to cool on the cookie sheet.

Melt chocolate and shortening together until quite runny. I do mine in the microwave, on medium heat for 30 second bursts stirring between each. This way it takes about 2 minutes. You can do it in the double boiler if you like.

Dip each cookie diagonally into the melted chocolate and allow excess to drip off. Place the dipped cookie on waxed paper and sprinkle the chocolate gently with a little minced pistachio or ginger, depending on the type of cookie. If you find that your ginger pieces stick together too much, try rubbing them together between your hands with a bit of powdered dried ginger to encourage them not to stick together.

http://gorgeoustown.typepad.com/lex_culinaria/2005/11/chocolate_dippe.html

 
Hmmm. The amounts do seem to be proportional.

I'm sure an egg wouldn't hurt the taste, but might affect the texture. How about adding more cream if the dough seems dry?

 
try baking a couple from the dough before you go and see how they turn out. the recipe sounds

like it should be fine as is.

 
Traca--I would have added a little more cream--the amounts of flour in baking...

recipes can vary depending on the measuring technique--dip & sweep, stirred & spooned, etc. Give them a try; you might have discovered something better than the original.

 
You guys are the best! I was confused because I don't make shortbread-type

cookies. So the first batch I did end up putting an egg in. But I had enough time and ingredients to make a second batch (as the recipe was originally written). We're going to do a taste test and try them BOTH, side by side. smileys/smile.gif

The types of cookies I normally bake are chewy...hence my thought that I needed an egg.

Ah well...I'm learning all the time over here! First I hunt down a HUGE mushroom...only to find out it's of the hallucinogenic variety and now this...It's turning out to be a banner week. LOL!

 
Back
Top