Cathy, here's my Mom's "recipe", with my notes interspersed. Sorry for the delay.
Semmelknoedel
1 loaf day old bread (I use a 24 oz. loaf)
1/2 cup milk (approximate)
1/2 bundle of parsley
Salt and pepper to taste (I use about 1 tsp. salt and 1/2 tsp. pepper, by eye)
4 eggs, beaten
1 cup flour (more for dusting)
Cut bread as small as possible. (I use standard, cheapo store loaves and cut to 1/4" to 1/3" dice.)
Place bread in a large bowl and soak with very little milk. (What does that mean, Mom? How do you "soak" something, but use "very little milk"? See what I mean? I dampen the bread and use about 1/2 cup.)
Let bread sit for awhile. (I let it sit until I chop the parsley and add the other ingredients.)
Chop parsley and sprinkle on top of bread. Add salt and pepper. (At this point I toss the bread cubes with the parsley, s & p to mix.)
Add 4 eggs and 1 cup flour. Mix with a large wooden spoon (hands) until "sticky".
Make into tennis-sized balls. (At this point the dough should hold together when cupped in your hands and formed into balls about the size of a tennis ball, or a little smaller. They will expand in the boiling water by at least 1/3. Dust your hands with flour and press the bread cubes firmly.) Roll in flour and let sit 10 min. (I dust a cutting board with flour and place the balls on it, scattering a little flour over the top.)
Bring large pot (16 quart) of water to a FULL boil. Make sure pot is large enough to hold all the knoedel. Place knoedel into the water. (When I pick up each knoedel to put it in the pot, I give it one last gentle squeeze, just to make sure it holds together. It's ok if the knoedel are in layers in the pot. Just stir it occasionally to submerge them evenly.)
Bring water back to boil and allow it to simmer, uncovered, for about 45 minutes to an hour. At 45 minutes, cut one knoedel open to check if it is cooked through. There can be a little stiff dough in the middle, but the knoedel should be damp most of the way through.
Drain the knoedel and serve with a sliced pot roast and PLENTY of rich, brown gravy.
My kids request this for their birthday dinners. It is simple, but very, very good.
Cathy, I'm sure you can decipher this, as you are truly an awesome cook. Please don't hesitate to ask questions if you need to.
Michael