My misadventures in Pumpkin Pie Making...

deb-in-mi

Well-known member
So it started at 6:30 a.m. this morning when I went to make the pie crust for our pumpkin pie. I was especially diligent - even chilling the flour in the fridge before cutting in the butter. Now I use the pie recipe from Zingerman's Bakehouse and although for the most part it works out beautifully for me - I sometimes think it's a tad dry. So I added 3 extra T. of butter to it (not realizing that this was actually nearly double the amount of fat called for). Anyway - I made the crust - and put it in the fridge to chill, then went to bake it off. Imagine my surprise 5 minutes later when I took a peek in the oven and I saw the crust sinking into the center of the pie plate and OOZING butter. But here's the kicker - it wasn't surprise that I felt but DEJA VU. It occurred to me that months ago when I made the pie I did the exact same thing and had to throw it out and start over. Aaargh! But before I threw it out I thought I would taste that soggy mass (hey - we're are talking butter here). And it tasted not so good - very different than what a pie crust normally tastes like - and not because of the butter. And then my eyes rested on the bag of flour I had used - bread flour (by mistake). Then I had another 'aha' moment as to why the malted chocolate chip cookies I took to my parents in Florida last week elicited a 'honey - these aren't very good - do you leave something out'from my father:)

Okay - made crust number two - following the directions and all turned out fine. Then I went to make the filling (I tried CI's latest recipe) and was a bit worked up at that point. The recipe called for using canned yams and I guess I didn't look at the picture on the can (hmmm...do you see a pattern here) and expected them to be mashed (um...I've never had a canned yam before) and I was so irritated and didn't want to dirty another pot to mash them in that I literally just put them in my (clean) hands and squeezed the daylights out of them. Until I had enough to make 1 cup, as the instructions called for.

As I continued to make the filling I noticed that the recipe called for 1 cup of cream and 1 cup of milk. But I hadn't noticed the latter item the first few times I read the recipe and didn't have any on hand. Just an extra 1/2 cup of cream. To which I topped it off with 1/2 cup of water.

The rest went well - we'll see tomorrow how it tastes. But I must tell you - I'm buying the pumpkin pie next year!

Deb

 
My sympathy...I'm pie crust challenged, but made one this afternoon. I, too, am hoping for the best.

 
Deb, it will be delicious, and your family will demand homemade pie again next year.

Sorry, but they will.

(I wonder if your bread flour has gone rancid somehow? It would make a brittle crust or cookie, but it shouldn't taste different from all-purpose.)

Happy Thanksgiving!

 
Is this a harbinger?

I've never used a "brining bag." I've brined my beloved bird in a 5 gallon food grade bucket for years. THIS year...I decided to use a bag. Neat, and complete...all the mess in one convenient place. Except for one minor thing...when I lifted the bag, the corner let loose... I have really good reflexes. We only lost about a quart. And it was really, really a good batch this year. The turkey is back in the lo-tech 5 gallon bucket.

 
Deb!! We just made the pumpkin pie and I must say, it's DELISH!! Next time, try this foolproof crust

perfect every time and takes, literally, just minutes!

Easiest Ever Mix Crust (never-fail!)
Better Homes and Gardens Magazine

Makes two 9” crusts

1-3/4 cups flour
1/2 tsp. salt
1/4 tsp. baking powder
2/3 cup shortening (Crisco)
1/4 cup cold water

In small mixer bowl, combine flour, salt and baking powder. Add shortening and beat with an electric mixer on low speed till ces are the size of small peas (about 15-20 seconds). Add water all at once; beat on low speed just till moistened (10-15 seconds). Form dough into a ball then divide in two. Roll as usual.

http://eat.at/swap/forum/index.php?action=display&forumid=1&msgid=97966

 
deb-in-MI, sounds like U had one of my 'better' pie making days! But if your Herculean efforts

fail to turn out a good pie, just explain to your guests that you tried a new recipe, and it sure didn't live up to what your expectations were because other recipes you've used from that same source have always come out so great in the past. !!! I've relied on that excuse for years! Best of luck to you today--wigs

 
Pumpkin Pie for Dummies (Deb, I feel your pain.)

This is my tried and true never fail but gets loads of compliments, pumpkin pie. Can't make pastry to save my life so I even use the Robin Hood mix which is very forgiving.

CREAMY PUMPKIN PIE

Pastry for 1 crust 9 inch pie
1 3/4 cups canned pumpkin (not pie filling)
15 oz can sweetened condensed milk
1 large egg
1/2 tsp. salt
1/2 tsp. cinnamon
1/4 tsp. nutmeg
1/4 tsp. cloves
1/4 tsp. ginger
1 cup hot water

Heat oven to 375° F. Line pie pan with pastry, building up a high fluted edge. Do not prick.

Beat remaining ingredients. Pour into pastry-lined pan. Bake 50 to 55 minutes, until knife inserted inside of filling comes out clean. Serve cold.

Note: I make leaf cutouts with the leftover pastry and bake them separately. Once the pie has cooled I decorate the top with the baked leaves.

A Margo Oliver Recipe

 
Thanks, Wigs. Actually I just found out that my niece bought a pumpkin pie - "just in case"smileys/smile.gif

 
Something's in the air - Pumpkin Pie and Pecan Tassies Adventure

I've decided I need to let my baking apprentice go (she's 2).

Tuesday night, prepping pecan tassies: She's sitting on the counter next to my work area, which I frequently allow. She's started to become more assertive - finally working her way over to try to grab the pecans as they are being chopped. End of sitting on the counter. Outside of some very hurt feelings, no injuries. In between drying the tears, I finish and fill the tins, thinking in the back of my mind that it sure seems like a lot of filling, and neglecting to read the instruction of fill each 3/4 full.....end result: 24 overflown, stuck in the pan tassies. They tasted good....after I pried them out of the pan.

Pumpkin Pie: Intend to start baking Wednesday morning, at 8:00 pm begin prepping first round. Apprentice decides she is quite ready for a bath and bed. Get said pies in oven, and proceed with bath/bed prep. Pies have about 15 minutes left, and apprentice decides she is absolutely not sleeping in her bed. In the interest of mommy's mental health - we all head to brother's room for the bunk beds. Everyone falls asleep. 10:43pm - Mom wakes up and runs to the kitchen, sighs, turns it off, and goes back to bed.

Begin step one again this morning......hopefully things will go better today! I hope the pumpkin pie turns out well - I had no more evaporated milk (yes, I make that pie) so subbed half and half......there is no way on earth I'm going to the store today.

 
Oh Deb--I am so sorry you have had such a challenging time with your pie!

I made my third pecan pumpkin pie this morning, in a greased and floured pie plate. Hopefully you will not need a stick of dynamite to get a slice of pie this time.....I'll have to get back to you on that after dinner!

The hostess of Thanksgiving dinner just called me and said she is worried about her pumpkin pie!!! Must be something in the air today! She said hers got too done around the edges but the center was still too jiggly. So, we may have two sad pies at our dinner! LOL!!!

I hope the rest of your cooking day goes well and that you have a wonderful Thanksgiving Dinner with your family and friends smileys/smile.gif

 
Thanks Barbara!

I'm sure yours are delicious!

I guess the thing is that I was SO looking forward to making that pie yesterday. I resigned from my job just over three weeks ago and a couple of unexpected opportunities have fallen in my lap. But to say I've been working on the 24/7...well - that's the truth (I'm dreaming about the stuff:)

Anyway - yesterday's "pie time" was to be a personal indulgement in something I love to do (baking/cooking). But as you can imagine, when you hand crush the yams because you are so irritated - it ain't looking so good.

Best to you and Mike!

 
Back
Top