Yes, I think it is real honey
I'm thinking those two reviewers either got a bad batch or maybe they're used to the thin grocery store commercial junk which I never buy. I am very particular about honey and I either buy imported German or local honey for the most part so that I know I'm getting real quality honey. There was an excellent local honey on Kauai that I also loved. Unfortunately, that is all gone now.
Also, the jar I bought was only $5. Much easier to try that way than the $18 markup that reseller is doing on Amazon.