Ok...I tried all 3 methods - cool water, baking soda/ice, and blown out
Forget trying to blow it out...my eyeballs would pop out before the egg would.
I cooked them all the same (in two separate pans), adding a little baking soda to one pan. Brought just to boil, covered, and steeped for 10 minutes. I covered the non-baking soda eggs in cool tap water to cool off like usual. The baking soda ones I dunked in the ice bath, cracked, then back in the ice bath. Result - all peeled about the same. No noticeable difference. All were eggs from an old carton dated July 5.
At least they all peeled...that hasn't happened for quite awhile. I'll stick with old eggs from now on smileys/smile.gif