Hi Lisa - I forgot about Scharffen Berger - I do like their chocolate a lot, especially the 70% -
not so much for eating out of hand, but definitely for baking. The ones I prefer for eating out of hand have less of the high notes, ie, have less acidic/tart flavors, and have more of the low notes, ie, have more of the deep, coffee taste. Scharffen Berger tends to have somewhat of a tart finish, but when using it in baking, I notice the acidic properties seem to dissolve.
I've baked with several "top" chocolates that I wasn't wild about when tasting them, and the end result was so-so, and some of them turned me off so much after tasting them that I didn't want to bake with them at all.
So far, my favorites for baking are: Ghirardelli 60% bittersweet and Ghirardelli semi-sweet, Santander 70% and Scharffen Berger 70%. Out of these 3 brands, Santander is the only one I eat out of hand. And as I mentioned above, my new discovery is Ghirardelli Espresso Escape, but I haven't baked with it yet.
This is always an interesting subject, since so many people agree and disagree on chocolate! For example, I know many people love El Rey, but I found their chocolates reminiscent of Ex Lax! As far as Valrhona, which is considered the king, I have not been impressed with any of their dark chocolates when eating them out of hand. Maybe if I baked with their chocolate, I'd like it better, but since it's not one of my favorite brands, and is very expensive on top of it all, why bother? smileys/smile.gif Actually, the only chocolates I like by Valrhona are their milk chocolates, 40 and 41% - they're really good.
What are your favorites?