Robicelli's cupcake/icing disaster...what a frustrating experience

marilynfl

Moderator
Last Sunday my local library organized a cupcake competition open to all ages. There would be no prizes...just judging for most "I have NO CLUE what! category since this Titanic combo never make it to the library.

Not realizing that disaster loomed ahead, I grabbed "Robicelli's: A Love Story, with Cupcakes: With 50 Decidedly Grown-Up Recipes" which is an ENTIRE BOOK dedicated to cupcakes, almost all which include some form of booze. Last year I fell in love with the prose in this library book...but never made any of the recipes. THAT was my first mistake. I have a standard rule that a minimum of THREE recipes must work for me BEFORE I buy the book.

What can I say...the flesh was weak.

Anyway, I searched the book and found The Noah cupcake, which is an apple-based cupcake, topped with mascarpone icing, bourbon-flavored drizzle and candied bacon. After reading that description, you should know that the ORIGINAL name (per the authors) was The Orgasmatron.

I actually had EVERY ingredient for this cupcake and so proceeded down a path lined with calories and unknown pitfalls. First off, a slight feeling of trepidation lingered while mixing the oil-based batter (similar to carrot cake) because the method was completely reversed. The eggs, which are usually beaten to a high volume with the sugar, were added at the very end and beaten for only 10 seconds. I should remember that stomach twinges may be a primal warning as opposed to just gastro-intestinal issues. I should remember that, but I didn't.

Then I used those cute tulip-shaped cupcake paper liners because...cute! I'm not exactly sure if that caused one of the issues, but it doesn't seemed to have helped.

TWENTY-FOUR cupcakes came out of the oven with a collapsed center. Okay, okay...I could deal with that. Core out the middle, fill with sauteed apples and move forward. But since I only needed 12 for the competition (and if you haven't met me yet, you should know I had NO INTENTION of entering a contest I didn't plan to win), I decided to taste one.

I could NOT get the darn thing off the "cute tulip-shaped" cupcake paper liner. Seriously, it was like I had brushed the inside paper with E6000 craft glue and then added the batter. I tested a second one and it also had to be peeled off the paper. The flavor was good, but that was all.

IMG_0377.JPG

So now there are TWO issues I was not happy with, but like a fool I decided to ignore my gut AGAIN and continue on to the icing. The book recommended their French buttercream, but I had already made that a few months ago and didn't want to waste SIX STICKS OF BUTTER AND FIVE EGGS for 12 cupcakes. The second recommendation was their American Buttercream, which uses powdered sugar, plus only THREE STICKS OF BUTTER, 8 OZ of MASCARPONE and 1/4 CUP of HEAVY CREAM. So, you know, the diet version.

Now I have been making icing since I was tall enough to stick beaters in a mixer and this one was an unmitigated disaster because it looked like mashed potatoes. Let me repeat: MASHED POTATOES! But sweet. There is no universe in which icing, meant to be light and fluffy, should look and taste like Bob Evan's mashed potatoes, sweet or otherwise.

So the contest was skipped. But now I was stuck with 22 collapsed cupcakes and an entire KA mixer full of sweet "mashed potatoes." So here's what I did to bring it as a dessert for a dinner I was invited to: The Orgasmatron Trifle

IMG_0378 2.jpg IMG_0381.jpg

Crumbled apple cupcakes

Vanilla pudding + weird icing + melted Lindt white chocolate + cream cheese

Apples sautéed in butter/cinnamon/apple brandy, then mixed with my applesauce

Whipped cream

My caramel thinned with reduced apple cider

Candied bacon

PS: I left off the bourbon drizzle. Mainly because there wasn't any bourbon left after drowning my sorrows.
PPS: The trifle was a success.
 
Last edited:
judy, even when using paper liners? Because this batter stuck to the paper. Plus I couldn't deliver 12 naked cupcakes to the library.

Oh wait...you line the tray with paper liners, then spray those?
 
Good save!!! (Mashed potatoes, wth?!)

Are the cupcake liners waxed, or just paper? I think the ones I use are waxed? I bought a lifetime supply of the dark brown go with anything cupcake liners when I was at a fancy cake supply store in San Francisco one time. It’s all I use after switching from those pastel colored ones from the grocery store of my youth.
 
Last Sunday my local library organized a cupcake competition open to all ages. There would be no prizes...just judging for most "I have NO CLUE what! category since this Titanic combo never make it to the library.

Not realizing that disaster loomed ahead, I grabbed "Robicelli's: A Love Story, with Cupcakes: With 50 Decidedly Grown-Up Recipes" which is an ENTIRE BOOK dedicated to cupcakes, almost all which include some form of booze. Last year I fell in love with the prose in this library book...but never made any of the recipes. THAT was my first mistake. I have a standard rule that a minimum of THREE recipes must work for me BEFORE I buy the book.

What can I say...the flesh was weak.

Anyway, I searched the book and found The Noah cupcake, which is an apple-based cupcake, topped with mascarpone icing, bourbon-flavored drizzle and candied bacon. After reading that description, you should know that the ORIGINAL name (per the authors) was The Orgasmatron.

I actually had EVERY ingredient for this cupcake and so proceeded down a path lined with calories and unknown pitfalls. First off, a slight feeling of trepidation lingered while mixing the oil-based batter (similar to carrot cake) because the method was completely reversed. The eggs, which are usually beaten to a high volume with the sugar, were added at the very end and beaten for only 10 seconds. I should remember that stomach twinges may be a primal warning as opposed to just gastro-intestinal issues. I should remember that, but I didn't.

Then I used those cute tulip-shaped cupcake paper liners because...cute! I'm not exactly sure if that caused one of the issues, but it doesn't seemed to have helped.

TWENTY-FOUR cupcakes came out of the oven with a collapsed center. Okay, okay...I could deal with that. Core out the middle, fill with sauteed apples and move forward. But since I only needed 12 for the competition (and if you haven't met me yet, you should know I had NO INTENTION of entering a contest I didn't plan to win), I decided to taste one.

I could NOT get the darn thing off the "cute tulip-shaped" cupcake paper liner. Seriously, it was like I had brushed the inside paper with E6000 craft glue and then added the batter. I tested a second one and it also had to be peeled off the paper. The flavor was good, but that was all.

View attachment 3692

So now there are TWO issues I was not happy with, but like a fool I decided to ignore my gut AGAIN and continue on to the icing. The book recommended their French buttercream, but I had already made that a few months ago and didn't want to waste SIX STICKS OF BUTTER AND FIVE EGGS for 12 cupcakes. The second recommendation was their American Buttercream, which uses powdered sugar, plus only THREE STICKS OF BUTTER, 8 OZ of MASCARPONE and 1/4 CUP of HEAVY CREAM. So, you know, the diet version.

Now I have been making icing since I was tall enough to stick beaters in a mixer and this one was an unmitigated disaster because it looked like mashed potatoes. Let me repeat: MASHED POTATOES! But sweet. There is no universe in which icing, meant to be light and fluffy, should look and taste like Bob Evan's mashed potatoes, sweet or otherwise.

So the contest was skipped. But now I was stuck with 22 collapsed cupcakes and an entire KA mixer full of sweet "mashed potatoes." So here's what I did to bring it as a dessert for a dinner I was invited to: The Orgasmatron Trifle

View attachment 3694 View attachment 3695

Crumbled apple cupcakes

Vanilla pudding + weird icing + melted Lindt white chocolate + cream cheese

Apples sautéed in butter/cinnamon/apple brandy, then mixed with my applesauce

Whipped cream

My caramel thinned with reduced apple cider

Candied bacon

PS: I left off the bourbon drizzle. Mainly because there wasn't any bourbon left after drowning my sorrows.
PPS: The trifle was a success.

OMGoodness! I think the way you 'saved & served' it was brilliant! I think I once tried one of their recipes and was less than enthused.
 
I make muffins once a week. Generally, it's a sit in the frig batter that I bake the next morning. Because the parchment cups have become so expensive...14 cents each, I now use one, for the one that I eat the next morning as they arrive from the oven, but the rest are the cheap paper type. Cheaper. The muffins almost jump out of the parchment liners, hot from the oven. On their own. Sans even a crumb of residue.

But the plain paper guys peel away easily once everyone is chilled, i.e. the next morning. I think the key there may be oil rather than butter in the batter.

And oh geez, either of those desserts would be a thrill for me. So beautifully contructed. I am such a sugar-piggy
 
Back
Top