CI published a taste test in Jan 2011
REC OMMENDED
Laurent Du Clos Red Wine Vinegar
“Good red wine flavor” won the day for this French import. Tasters liked the “nicely rich,” “well-balanced,” and
“fruity” flavor that came through in the pickled onions, and they praised the “clean, light, pleasant taste” and
“subtle zing” it added to the vinaigrette.
$3.99 for 16 fl. oz. (25
cents per oz.)
RECOMMENDED
Pompeian Gourmet Red Wine Vinegar
Tasters were enthusiastic about this “very mild, sweet, pleasant” red wine vinegar with “tang” that was in
“harmonious balance.” It was “not harsh at all,” but had a “bright, potent taste” with “really pleasing red wine
flavor.”
$5.99 for 16.9 fl. oz. (35
cents per oz.)
RECOMMENDED WITH RESERV A TIONS
Spectrum Naturals Organic Red Wine Vinegar
Tasters praised our former favorite supermarket brand’s “winy” and “fruity” taste with “buttery” and “briny”
undertones, but it stumbled in the pickled onions, inspiring remarks about its “watery,” “thin,” and “wimpy”
flavor.
$3.99 for 12 fl. oz. (33
cents per oz.)
RECOMMENDED WITH RESERVATIONS
Heinz Gourmet Red Wine Vinegar
Tasted on its own, this domestic red wine vinegar was deemed “bright and sweet with good red wine flavor.”
Once cooked, however, a few tasters noticed a “sour, almost fermented taste” that was “too harsh” to let the
wine flavor through.
$2.89 for 12 fl. oz. (24
cents per oz.)
REC OMMENDED WITH RESERV A TIONS
Holland House Red Wine Vinegar
Some tasters liked its “tart,” “fruity,” and “cherry/nectarine” notes, but this vinegar also received the most
complaints about its “acetone” or “nail polish remover” smell and taste.
$2.49 for 12 fl. oz. (21
cents per oz.)
RECOMMENDED WITH RESERVATIONS
Regina Red Wine Vinegar
Distinguishing itself with its perceived sweetness, this vinegar with “berry” and “floral” notes didn’t offend, nor
did it wow tasters, whose comments included “middle-of-the-road quality” and “no zip or zing.”
$2.99 for 17 fl. oz. (18
cents per oz.)
RECOMMENDED WITH RESERVATIONS
Colavita Red Wine Vinegar
Some tasters appreciated this vinegar’s “winy and sweet” flavor and “nice balance” with “just the right tang.”
Others, however, found it “harsh,” “sour,” and “sharp” with a “saccharine aftertaste.”
$2.39 for 12 fl. oz. (20
cents per oz.)
RECOMMENDED WITH RESERVATIONS
Star Red Wine Vinegar
This vinegar had a “bright and zippy” presence in vinaigrette and a “refreshing bite” in the pickled onions, but
its lack of “real red wine taste” allowed the acidity to prevail, making it harsh for some.
*PRICES SUBJECT TO CHANGE
$9.99 for 8.5 oz. ($1.18 per
oz.)
RECOMMENDED WITH RESERVATIONS
Lucini Pino Noir Italian Wine Vinegar
“Pucker city!” wrote one taster about this “strong” and “punchy” Tuscan import, the most acidic vinegar we
tasted. But one taster in the vinaigrette round claimed, “It’s the first time … I’ve picked out red wine flavor.”
$3.99 for 16.9 fl. oz. (24
cents per oz.)
RECOMMENDED WITH RESERVATIONS
Monari Federzoni Red Wine Vinegar
This “strong, pungent, and jarring” Italian vinegar garnered little praise from our tasters because of its
overwhelming acidity. One wrote, “I’d like the sample better if it wasn’t so harsh. It has nice sweetness and
flavor.” A few tasters liked its “robust, aged flavor” and thought it was “tangier than the others” in a vinaigrette.