Hi Dawn>>>
When I lived in NY we used to go to Arthur Ave weekly. It is very safe and probably one of the very few true Italian enclaves left.
After we moved here to PA about 90 minutes away from the Bronx our trips were more monthly. I have not been since Keith passed and I really miss it.
You will never have better pizza than they make at Full Moon and if you can, go to Dominic's for dinner. It's the best, you sit at long tables with people you don't know, the waiter who is also your chef will come out and tell you what they are making that evening. Of course if you want something different, they will make that too. They put a fresh loaf of Addeo's bread on the table ( the best bread in NY, I went to school with the Addeo boys so it's a loyality thing) and you have the best time and make new friends,
Go to the retail Market to Mike's for proscuitto,pancetta and other cold cuts, Calandra's for cheese, ( Mike's cheese is very good too, and Mike likes to sing opera while he "works" sipping a glass of wine, his kids really run the place now) Vincent's for meat (great osso bucco and sausage) Addeo's for bread and pepper breadsticks, and for pastry's head around the block to 187th St to Eguido's. Cannoli's that will rock your world.
The only problem with the weekend, is the parking, for some reason it has sadly become something of a tourist attraction, although I cannot see why anyone would drag their very bored children for a day of food shopping, however they do. Hopefully the novelity has worn off and it's back to normal once again. They have parking lots off the street and they are really reasonable and there is an attendant on duty.
If you are any way squeemish, avoid looking in the windows of the meat markets, they hang the whole pig, goat, rabbit whatever right in plain view. My sister never got used to it.
Anyway in my mind, it is well worth the trip. Bring your cooler, and a large tote bag to haul your goodies around in because you will have bags from lots of places and might misplace one if you run out of hands to carry them. I have a big Land's End one that I keep in the car for the Arthur Ave trip.
marg