Here you go...I found it on old Gail's after Gay gave the archive url # again.
Forum Home Page: Archive Swap 101 to 200
Re: BUTTERSCOTCH PIE LIKE GRANDMA MADE IN THE 1920'S! (Sandi Crowder)
Previous Message: Need more information to find the recipe (Cathy Zadel)
Date: Thu, 02 Nov 1995 18:38:40 GMT
From: Cathy Zadel (@kauai-52.u.aloha.net ())
Butterscotch Pie
Hi Sandi- I did some pretty extensive research
and came up with the following recipes. I kept
stumbling over what you told me about the kids
that would snatch the little candy balls- It
didn't fit into the recipes in my mind until I
realized that when you carmelize sugars, you
test them by dropping a bit into a cup of cold
water to see how firm the candy is (soft or hard
ball stage) EUREKA, I said!!! That must be what
Grandma was talking about. Butterscotch Pies were
all the rage in the teens, twenties and into the
thirties and I found many, many similar recipes
for them. Most say to cook the brown sugar mix
only 5 minutes but I am positive it is a longer
time on today's ranges. The one I think may
come the closest to your Grandmother's recollection
is the Brown Brittle Pie from the Hotel Anderson
Cookbook- gosh, I HOPE I found one that will make
her smile. Let me know- Cathy
BUTTERSCOTCH PIE
St. Mark's Guild Cookbook, Lake City, Minnesota 1925
Part I: 2 egg yolks, 1 tbsp flour, 1 cup milk
Part II: Melt piece of butter size of walnut
in skillet, put in 1 cup brown sugar, add 4
tbsp milk. Cook 5 minutes. Add Part I and
cook slowly until thick. Put in baked pie
shell.
BUTTER SCOTCH PIE (WITH MILK)
Women of Bethlehem Church, Minneapolis, Minnesota 1922
Melt and mix together 1 cup brown sugar,
2-1/2 tbsp butter, 2 tbsp milk, cook this
mixture slowly for 5 minutes. Have ready:
3 tbsp flour blended with 1 cup milk, 2 egg
yolks and 1 tsp vanilla. Combine with other
mixture and cook until done. Put in a ready
baked shell. Cover with meringue and brown.
BUTTER SCOTCH PIE (WITH WATER)
Women of Bethlehem Church, Minneapolis, Minnesota 1922
1 cup brown sugar, yolks of 2 or 3 eggs,
2 tbsp flour, 2 tbsp butter, 1 cup water.
Cook in double boiler. When thick, put in
shell and top with meringue made from egg
whites. Place in oven and brown.
BUTTERSCOTCH PIE
The New Delineator Recipes, Butterick
Publishing, Chicago 1929
1-1/2 cup milk
1 cup brown sugar
3 tbsp cornstarch
2 eggs
2 tbsp butter
2 tbsp powdered sugar
Heat one cup of milk and the sugar until the
sugar is free from lumps. Mix the cornstarch,
1/2 cup of milk and egg yolks and add to the
hot mixture slowly. Cook in a double boiler
until thick, stirring constantly, then for 10
minutes longer. Add butter. When cool, pour
into a baked shell and cover with a meringue
made from the stiffly beaten egg-whites and
powdered sugar. Brown in the oven.
BROWN BRITTLE PIE
Hotel Anderson Cookbook, Jeanne Hall, M.Barrows
Pub. 1939
1/4 cup butter
2/3 cup brown sugar, firmly packed
1/2 tsp salt
1-2/3 cup milk
2 tbsp cornstarch
2 tbsp pastry flour
3 eggs, separated
1 tbsp butter
3/4 tsp vanilla
1 baked 9" Pecan Pastry shell
6 tbsp sugar
brown sugar
Melt the butter and add the brown sugar, salt
and about 2/3 cup of the milk. Caramelize this
mixture, 210 degrees, and add 1/2 cup of the
milk. Mix the cornstarch and flour with the
remaining milk. Beat the egg yolks and add
to the caramelized mixture. Cook until clear. Add the tbsp of butter and the vanilla. Beat the egg whites until stiff and mix in the 6 tbsp of white sugar. Fold half of the beaten egg whites into the cooked mixture. (Reserve the remainder for the meringue topping) Pour into the cooled pastry shell. Spread the meringue topping on the cooled pie filling, smoothing with a
spatula. Sift some brown sugar over the top
and brown quickly under the broiler flame.