I have seen that movie Amanda. I found it to be largely factual, but very...
...slanted.
What we are seeing is the result of an inadequate and largely ineffectual Federal immigration policy. The mexicans have been here for a long time, filling these jobs. Take them all away, all at once (a day without a mexican) and you will have chaos. Of COURSE you would!
Take away all the nurses at once, or all the "moms" and see what the effect would be. Take away all the sanitation workers at once and you have what cities back east incur when the workers strike. So, in my opinion, the "day without a mexican" premise has to be measured against this.
And, also, is it safe to assume that motel beds got made, crops got picked and landscaping was maintained years BEFORE the mexicans came across the border? No one else will do these jobs because the mexicans have done them for decades. Given no more mexicans, as the movie proposes, things would come to a halt. Then, slowly, these jobs would get done again, by someone.
Not a fair representation of reality, in my opinion.
Keep in mind that I was raised in Southern California. My social world has always included a large melting pot of people from all cultures, including mexicans, pacific islanders, asians, americans of african descent, etc. From the time I was a little guy, our school system, and my home life, taught me to respect and value all cultures. I appreciate the differences, and especially like all that goes with an ethnically diverse population.
I don't like beer cans on front lawns; cars parked on front lawns; bonfires nightly; school children and the elderly being harrassed by day laborers lining the streets; illegal immigrants dying in the heat of the desert; 25 people living in single family starter homes; kids who are not taught english and the expectation that our public schools should do that, at the expense of the taxpayer and english-speaking students who can't get taught because the teacher has to speak mostly to the non-english speakers; ER's and maternity wards closing, and hospitals going bankrupt because illegal aliens are there getting free healthcare; etc., etc.
I could go on and on. Social responsibility is everyone's duty, in my book. Illegal aliens among us seek a better life, but in the process the face of our neighborhoods and communities takes a huge hit.
Michael